• 5 stars
  • 4 stars
  • 3 stars
  • 2 stars
  • 1 stars

5 out of 5 based on 72 ratings.
62 user reviews.
Kim Mills
See My Zillow Profile
(72 ratings)

Kim was fantastic! She patiently walked us through getting our house ready for the market, all of our questions, and the emotional ups-and-downs of selling our home of 18 years. Not to mention, she brought the right buyer quickly! The whole process was as smooth as it possibly could be thanks to all of Kim's hard work and advice. Thank you so much!

Laura A Gill

Kim was amazing! Incredibly helpful, prompt, and responsive. We bought with her, sold with her, and would definitely work with her again. Her recommendations, including staging helped us get the most out of selling our home!

Tiffany White

Kim went above and beyond to promote and sell our home. I will refer her to all our friends and clients looking to sell or buy their next home.

Traci Bentine Richardson

Kim worked with us for ten years (10!) to find the right house for our family and never gave up. She's a true professional who never loses sight that this is a major decision for your family and will be your trusted advisor when you need one. Kim only wants the best for her clients and will help champion you through the process from the first day until after you move in.

Jamie Barcelona

Super happy with Kim. First time buyer and she made the process smooth and seamless. Would definitely use her again.

David Dutson

Kim is great!

Evan Cochran

Kim was amazing , guiding us through the whole process of buying our first house.

Richard Davila

Kim did a great job in securing our new home. A pleasure working with her.

Karen Griffin

Kim Mills made the whole process smooth and effortless. We are very appreciative of all her hard work

Alex Collins

Kim was/is great. She was able to quickly understand our needs and offer advice and suggestions accordingly. She also created a very relaxed atmosphere for a normally stressful activity, was very accommodating to our schedule and we never felt rushed. I will highly recommend her to friends/family in need of a realtor.

Marc T Adams

Kim has a great eye for presenting the house in a beautiful way. She worked hard to get feedback from potential buyers throughout the process and encouraged us to be flexible as the market shifted slightly during the summer. We really appreciated Kim's effort and attitude.

Bryce Thornton

We highly recommend Kim Mills for her honesty and her ability to communicate clearly. She did a great job walking us through the whole process.

Earl E. Uday, Jr.

We would recommend Kim Mills to any friend and hope to keep in contact with her. It was a positive experience working with her.

Vicki L. Uday

Kim is so helpful! She knows the market and how to maximize your profits!!

Brenda Faye Williams

Kim was always available to assist us with any questions we had. Very personable and professional. A pleasure to work with.

Karen Griffin

Kim is always a joy. She genuinely wants to help her clients, and she does this by listening. This is the second time Kim has helped us buy a family home (plus sell the first home), and once again she did an amazing job. Kim is responsive, detailed, and knowledgeable. I will recommend her to my family and friends all day long.

Laura Barber Purvis

Kim was amazing. Thank you so much.

Jesse Webster

Kim is patient and attentive to her clients. We moved from out of state and it was difficult because we couldn’t physically be there for most of the process. She helped ease our anxiety through the stressful parts of this process while staying focused on all the other the necessary details. She is amazing!!

Sara Webster

This is the second time we have worked with Kim to purchase a home. She took our family's needs into consideration every step of the way. She was a joy to work with the entire time and went above and beyond more than once. While we're excited to move into our new home, we are sad to no longer work closely with Kim.

Laura Purvis

We were able to successfully put together a deal very quickly in a super competitive market. Great network of people in varies fields to assist. Thanks!

Andrew Heiser

I've worked with Kim on both a real estate purchase and a sale. Her attention and attention to detail is as attentive, clear and focused as any professional with whom I've worked! She returns calls and texts immediately, has a thorough knowledge of the process, navigating transactions and conversations with skill, ease, and professionalism. Kim's grace and poise position her team and Cutler at the top. Just wow.

Richard Jeffers

Kim did amazing job. By far the best realtor experience we ever had. She’s very accommodating

Italo DiPrisco

We greatly appreciated all of Kim’s help and guidance throughout the entire process! She’s the best!

Megan Bamberger

Kim did an outstanding job helping me find the perfect house. The market is aggressive right now and she did a great job helping me with my contract and walking me through the entire process!

Katie Hill

Kim has made our home buying process seamless and smooth! She facilitated a simple negotiating process and had excellent recommendations, and was so engaged and helpful. I would absolutely recommend her and her team! It was a joy getting to work with her.

Isabel Marie Manzanillo-DeVore

I wouldn't want to work with any realtor other than Kim!

Jamie Barcelona

Kim Mills is a thoughtful and truthful realtor that I could trust to make some of the moves for me and push me in the right direction. She has a quick response time and worked diligently to make sure everything was done correctly in the right time period. I would use Kim time and time again.

Michael Samson

KIM is the epitome of an excellent realtor. She worked tirelessly for us, even while on vacation. She listened to our needs and was constantly thinking of smart, innovative ways to help us sell our house. She was in constant communication and was available to help us through each and every step. I would recommend her to anyone who’s interested in buying or selling and will only ever work with her for our next move.

Daniel Deckant

Kim is the absolute best. She really cares about her clients and goes above and beyond to help them and make them feel comfortable during a stressful process.

Michael Miller

Kim is highly professional and a client centered individual. I would recommend her for any real estate needs!

Brenda Williams

Kim did a great job and was extremely flexible in taking us to see houses when it was convenient for us. Once we were in closing she answered all of our questions extremely quickly and we were never waiting for a resolution on her end. I would absolutely recommend her and use her in the future!

Richard Art

Kim Mills was AMAZING. This was our first time buying a house and we felt so comfortable with her.

Lindsey Clary

Kim was really great to work with!

Vincent Allen

Kim is awesome! She had helped us buy our house four years earlier, and then recently helped us sell the same place in Clintonville. For the recent sale she did a fantastic job, right from staging the house perfectly, to hiring a outstanding photographer, and then handling all the subsequent offers and paperwork. Throughout the whole process she was really responsive and we didn't have to worry about a thing. If you're looking to buy or sell I highly recommend working with Kim.

M. Wilkins

Kim was receptive to our house preferences and found us listings that were relevant. We often communicated with her via text and e-mail and she responded quickly. She was very honest in pointing out pros and cons of each house, and didn't try to show us houses out of our price range unless she truly thought it matched our personality and our must-haves. We were able to view houses very quickly with her.

A. Way

Our family has relocated multiple times and Kim Mills sincerely delivered the highest level of service and results we have ever experienced in our 23 years of home ownership. From the beginning of the home sale process through final closing, Kim's expertise in all areas of the business made our home sale a true success.

D. Rubadeux

Kim had tremendous knowledge of the local market but even more important she listened to our needs. Kim also showed a great deal of patience for our entire family.

Pat McDonagh

Kim Mills did an outstanding job of helping us find the perfect downtown Columbus home. Her knowledge of the downtown and individualized properties that spanned from condos to single-family homes was wonderful. She did a great job of representing us as buyers from the first offer through our final closing.

K. McHugh

Kim was fantastic to work with for purchasing our first home! She was patient,, knowledgable,, trustworthy,, and overall a great person! Her professionalism and expertise helped us to find the perfect home. Would (and personally will be) highly recommending her to all friends and family in the area.

Ali Augsburger

If you need help finding a home in the Columbus,, OH area look no further than Kim Mills. Buying a house is stressful,, so what a relief it was having someone like Kim by our side. Super responsive,, knowledgeable,, and patient she guided us through a tough market and found our perfect house!

Derek Augsburger

Kim was incredible to work with in the process of purchasing my condo. As a first time home buyer,, I had so many questions. From helping me with my initial research to find an area and home type that fit my needs to the closing process,, Kim was incredibly helpful. She always took time with me to explain each step of the process and was always available to chat. She is great to work with and I have recommended her to friends and co-workers who are looking to purchase homes in the Central Ohio area.

Jordan Martin

Kim is amazing at what she does. She listened to our needs and wants and was able to find us the perfect home. My stress level has never been so low during the home-buying process. It was like shopping with a friend. I cannot recommend her enough!,

Laura Purvis

Kim was amazing. She was always available to help. And quick to respond. Her personality is wonderful and made the entire process much easier. We'll definitely use her again.

D. Mason

My wife and I were first-time homebuyers, and Kim did an amazing job of guiding us through the process and helping us to buy our home in Worthington. She was highly responsive to our numerous questions and always let us come to our own conclusions and decisions when it came to negotiating with our seller. I would highly recommend her to someone looking to buy a home in Columbus.

Will Woodworth

Kim could not be more engaged and responsive! She texted back within minutes EVERY time and her warm and caring demeanor really defined the transaction for me. You will struggle to find an agent who is more dialed in to what you need in your search or (I assume) sale.

T. J.

My wife and I were first-time homebuyers,, and Kim did an amazing job of guiding us through the process and helping us to buy our home in Worthington. She was highly responsive to our numerous questions and always let us come to our own conclusions and decisions when it came to negotiating with our seller. I would highly recommend her to someone looking to buy a home in Columbus.

Will Woodworth

We worked with Kim to buy our first home in Clintonville. We sold it because we needed some more space and we found what we needed in Old Worthington. She was committed to find exactly what we wanted and was always available to answer our questions. She is extremely easy to work with and made the entire process as smooth as possible

Mike Graziani

Kim Mills was our agent when we sold our condo as well as purchased our new home. She was wonderful to work with and made the whole process enjoyable, we definitely recommend her to anyone and plan to use her in the future when it's time to move again. When selling our condo, she made wonderful suggestions to help stage it and we received and negotiated an offer much more quickly then we expected to. When looking for new homes, she arranged showings as soon as we requested to see a home, and was very flexible and able to work around our busy schedule for showings (evenings and weekends). After deciding on the home we wanted to make an offer on, she made the entire process run smoothly with minimal stress. Overall, buying and selling with her was a wonderful experience and we look forward to working with her in the future!

Maria S.

Kim Mills was my neighbor before I hired her as my realtor. She's professional, considerate, personable, and detail-oriented. She goes the extra yard to help your listing stand out in the crowd. She also helped us find our new home in just one day. She knows in a buyer's market that timing is everything, and will take the time to get the job done for you. I could not think of a better person to work with to not only sell my house, but to help me find my new home.

Ann Ralston

Kim is just wonderful! She is very calm, let's you explore as much as you need and has great advice. We have worked with her for 3+ years, bought our first home in Columbus, then sold it to buy a bigger one and found the next home, all with Kim's help!

Laura Feitl

Kim was very familiar with the areas in town where we wanted to move. She was a great listener and figured out pretty quickly what properties to show us. We will use Kim again and recommend her to friends.

Amy Shore

I was very pleased how Kim listened to me and my needs, even when I wasn't sure that they were! She made the process of moving from out of state so easy with her knowledge of the Columbus area and staying on top of what was available. I love my condo and would work with Kim again in a heartbeat!

Brenda W.

I cannot say enough about my experience with Kim. She made our home buying experience fun and less stressful. When a house came on the market, I remember texting Kim at 10pm, hoping we could visit the house the next day. She was always prompt with her replies and would magically get us a house tour the next day. While exploring several homes, Kim helped us visualize a home versus an empty house. If you want someone knowledgeable, reliable and personable, Kim Mills is perfect for you.

Mandy N.

As a first time home buyer, Kim was the best! Her knowledge and expertise was top notch. Not to mention, she was the most wonderful person to work with. I even referred her to family members and friends who used her with buying and selling their homes as well. I will definitely be working with Kim when I eventually sell my house/buy my next house!

Kim Zeller

Worked with us on price, was very frank about what she thought the house would go for. Very responsive and guided us through each and every step with ease. When we got an offer she was able negotiate effectively with the other realtor that we ended up coming out monetarily ahead of what we thought we would. All in all a great experience.

David Suski

Nancy and I had talked for years about moving downtown and living the city life. After talking with some friends who had already taken the plunge we decided to dip our toes in the water. Our friends recommended that we work with Kim and we are grateful that we did. Kim's knowledge of downtown and the surrounding areas allowed us to very quickly find a condo that met all of our requirements, was in a great location, and had a fabulous view. Since we felt so comfortable with Kim we had her list our home as well. This was when Kim's ability as a realtor was put to the test. She gave us good advice on how to make our home show well, resulting in a full price offer within 12 hours of going on the market. All seemed perfect until we left for vacation. While we were gone, the buyer's appraisal came in too low and since they were young first-time buyers they were unable to make up the difference. This was a problem since we were relying on the sale of our home for the down payment on the condo. I did not handle this situation with grace and calm! Fortunately, Kim was there to take my frantic, emotional calls at odd hours from another timezone and talk me down off the ledge. She remained cool, calm and confident throughout. She reassured me that we have a great house and should have no problem dropping these buyers and finding another. She was right of course! The house went back on the market and was in contract within 24 hours. During all this, she also worked with our lender we were using to purchase the condo. They were able to quickly restructure our financing to allow us to close on the condo as planned and provide the down payment from the home sale later. I am very grateful for Kim's competent professionalism throughout this process and would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Trent Brown

Recently, Kim helped us purchase a home in Grandview. This is our seventh house - so we are no stranger to the process. This was by far the smoothest real estate transaction we have ever had. Kim was remarkably quick to pick up our wants and needs regarding space, style, and location. She did a great job of pointing out both pros and cons of the many houses we toured. Kim was also excellent in handling the little glitches presented by the seller at closing. She did a great job from start to finish.

Adam + Juli Cavnar

We were brand new to the Columbus area and our family of 4 had no idea where to look first. It only took a few moments with Kim Mills and we knew she could help us. The most significant attribute I could say about Kim is that she fully engaged with us and learned what would be best for us. This saved a great amount of time and every house she showed us was a true prospect - leading to the one we now call home.

Pete Hixson

When we purchased our home in Upper Arlington we were working at a distance from the East Coast with no easy way to vet houses before committing to fly into the city. Kim provided an initial assessment of any home we were interested in pursuing to determine whether or not it seemed to be a good match for our needs and wants. Her extensive network and previous experience with the seller's realtor allowed us to move quickly on a house the day it appeared on the market. This opened up lines of communication that would not be afforded to us otherwise and led to a bid being submitted within 48 hours of the house being listed, which we closed on. Our home and neighborhood provide the perfect mix of excellent schools for our kids, proximity to the center of town, and value. It was a very positive experience.

Matt Anderson

As a first time buyer I was really nervous about making the right choice. Kim was so helpful in helping me weigh out all my options, providing me comparable rates, and helped me find a lender! It was a wonderful experience and I would recommend her to anyone! Her market knowledge is top notch!

Elizabeth Burson

Working with Kim was great, and fast! She made some suggestions for staging our condo, chose a fantastic photographer, and within 24 hours of listing, we had two full price offers. Kim also helped with buying our new home. It was a very smooth process.

Jacob Yount

Kim patiently walked us through and explained the process of selling our home. She made the entire experience as stress free as possible. The next time that I am in need of a realtor, Kim will be my first call.

Michael Snee

Kim Mills represented us as a selling and buying realtor. She came highly recommended to us, and we were very satisfied with the process. She demonstrated a high level of professionalism, responded in a timely manner, and was very courteous. She has insight into the Columbus housing market value and as well as solid partnerships. She provided sound advice when needed and we recommend Kim. Thank you Kim!


Kim was so great to work with! She helped us sell our home and buy our next home. We trusted her opinion and felt confident she was giving us the best possible advice. Thanks so much Kim!!!


Kim was fantastic every step of the way and made the process seamless. As a first time homebuyer, finding a realtor that you can trust is very important, and Kim exceed all expectations.


Her contacts and ability to sell at or above market are exceptional. We closed quickly and received above what we wanted for our property. Her team she choose from Stewart Title were very professional and responsive. And her own team did really well with followup. I think the Columbus market is extremely hot right now, so this may have skewed it some in her favor. Never the less, it went very well.


We started working with Kim nearly two years before we bought the house of our dream, clearly with her help.

Our transition from Knoxville, Tennessee to Columbus, Ohio took longer than anticipated. We were unsure about the timing of buying a house in Columbus and equally uncertain about our price range. This is a terrible situation for a real estate agent, who had to deal with several "degrees of freedom" (sorry, I am a scientist) when dealing with her customers. We applaud Kim for not just bearing with us during this time, but for helping us to navigate through these uncertainties with patience, understanding, knowledge, and grace. Once we zoomed into New Albany as our future home site, Kim worked hard to get us all the information we needed and with her help we've got several peaks into properties that were just about to hit the market. She stayed with us during our hesitations (price versus location versus good deal versus prestige) without pushing, but always with a good advice and her own perspective on things.
To make the long story short, we bought the house of our dream (well, actually, well above our dreams) and it wouldn't happen without Kim.

We are proud to have had Kim as our real estate agent. Key words for our experience with Kim Mills: knowledge, reliability, excellence, trust, warmness, friend.


Kim was easy to work with and constantly kept us updated. She handled the sale of our house and our purchase of a condo. She was especially effective guiding us through the closing process for both transactions. We found Kim friendly and readily available with advice and help. Marie & Joe Hallett.


Seven years. It took us 7 years of fits and starts on the home buying journey to find the right home and Kim never gave up on us or made us feel like a lower priority. She never tired of showing us homes that we discovered or pinging us with new homes that she thought met our goals for a next home.

She's a complete professional and she's always current and candid with you about what's happening in the market.

When it comes time for the offer process the contract and all of the emotions that go with it, she meets you where you are and guides you step-by-step through the process all the way up until you have the keys to your new home in hand. She is truly focused on YOUR goals, not just trying to complete transactions. I can't imagine going through the home buying or selling process with anyone else.


We have bought and sold 2 homes with Kim. She is intelligent, hard working, responsive and a true pleasure to work with. Can’t say enough good things about her, HIGHLY recommend

brent m hausfeld

Kim is awesome! She had helped us buy our house four years earlier, and then recently helped us sell the same place in Clintonville. For the recent sale she did a fantastic job, right from staging the house perfectly, to hiring a outstanding photographer, and then handling all the subsequent offers and paperwork. Throughout the whole process she was really responsive and we didn't have to worry about a thing. If you're looking to buy or sell I highly recommend working with Kim.

Mike Wilkins

Our family has relocated multiple times and Kim Mills sincerely delivered the highest level of service and results we have ever experienced in our 23 years of home ownership. From the beginning of the home sale process through final closing, Kim's expertise in all areas of the business made our home sale a true success.


Login to My Homefinder

Login to My Homefinder